|
Books With his limitations, forgotten Benedict was a good pope
THE UNKNOWN
POPE: BENEDICT XV (1914-1922) AND THE PURSUIT OF PEACE By John F.
Pollard Geoffrey Chapman, 256 pages, $29.95,
hardcover |
By GARY MacEOIN
We have had nine popes in this century, and every one except
Giacomo Della Chiesa (Benedict XV) -- even John Paul I whose pontificate lasted
only 33 days -- is well represented in books in print. Before the present work
there were only two short-lived biographies of Benedict XV in English, one in
1940, the other in 1959. Benedict deserved better, if only for his reversal of
the crusade against Modernism conducted by his predecessor.
Born into an old Italian family, the future pope studied in
prestigious Roman universities, including the Academy of Noble Ecclesiastics.
In 1881 he graduated to the Roman curia where Cardinal Mariano Rampolla del
Tindaro, who in 1887 became Leo XIIIs secretary of state, took him under
his wing. At the conclave following Leos death in 1903, Rampolla was the
strongest candidate until the Austro-Hungarian emperor interposed his veto,
ensuring the election of Giuseppe Sarto as Pius X. This affected Della
Chiesas future negatively in the short run but in the end worked to his
benefit.
Church historian and longtime NCR Vatican correspondent
Peter Hebblethwaite, in his biography of Pope John XXIII, identified Della
Chiesa as one of the first victims of the crusade against Modernism, this
synthesis of all heresies, as Pius X called his never clearly
defined enemy. All the efforts of theologians, biblical scholars and church
historians to use modern scientific methods in their work were anathema to him.
In his zeal he purged seminaries, theological faculties and the priesthood,
imposing an anti-Modernist oath on all clergy.
Della Chiesa was no Modernist. But he had become an outsider in
the curia when Cardinal Merry Del Val replaced Rampolla as secretary of state.
Della Chiesa was removed from the center of power by being named archbishop of
Bologna in 1907.
Ironically, Bologna gave him the pastoral experience that made him
a candidate for the papacy when Pius died in 1914. The curial cardinals wanted
a pope who would continue the inquisitorial policies of Pius. Residential
cardinals had seen for themselves the harm this policy had done in their
dioceses. It was a bitter fight, taking 17 ballots for Della Chiesa to reach
the necessary two-thirds. Even then the curialists did not yield gracefully.
They insisted on having Della Chiesas ballot examined to ensure that he
had not voted for himself.
In Bologna Della Chiesa had made clear his dislike of the
anti-Modernist witch hunt, and as pope, he did not disappoint his electors. He
quickly removed the anti-Modernist leaders from their positions of influence.
In his first encyclical -- Ad Beatissimi -- he laid down a set of
guidelines that were very different from those Pius had used to judge
orthodoxy. In matters about which the Holy See has not given a decision,
and in which, without injury to the faith and ecclesiastical discipline, there
may be differences of opinion, each may lawfully defend his own. In such
disputes there must be no offensive language, for this may lead to grave
breaches of charity.
Benedicts eight-year reign was marked by the cataclysm of
World War I, the establishment of communism in Russia, and the Versailles Peace
Treaty, which contained the seeds of yet another world conflagration. All of
these were issues of extreme importance to the Catholic church. And Benedict
spared no effort to influence them in the direction he believed best served the
churchs needs.
His success was limited. His appeals to prevent the outbreak of
war went unheard, and his various efforts to end it were ignored by the
belligerents. His greatest success was in helping prisoners of war, arranging
exchanges of prisoners, creating lines of communication between prisoners and
their families. A bureau in the Vatican created in 1915 dealt with 600,000
items of correspondence, including 170,000 inquiries about missing persons,
40,000 appeals for help to repatriate sick prisoners of war, and the forwarding
of 50,000 letters to and from prisoners and their families.
The Allied blockade caused widespread hunger, and Benedict spent
beyond his resources to alleviate it. He played a major role in raising funds
internationally to relieve the famine in Russia in 1921. Thanks to his
intervention, an obscure appeal by two English women for funds for the starving
children of Austria and Hungary became a world movement whose activities still
continue, the Save the Children Fund.
The tone of this biography is unnecessarily defensive. Benedict
was a typical ecclesiastical bureaucrat of his day. He was obsessed by the idea
that his primary job was to restore the temporal power of the papacy. He
worried that the war would destroy the Catholic Austro-Hungarian
Empire and increase the influence of Protestant Germany. He was
horrified that Russia might occupy Constantinople, reconvert Santa Sophia from
a mosque to a cathedral and place Orthodoxy on a level with Rome. Better, he
thought, to leave it to the infidels.
Benedict was not John XXIII. He saw his role as defending the
church as institution rather than as placing the institution at the service of
humanity. But he was a good pope with all his limitations, which included a
short temper. That is already a lot to expect from the head of any major
institution. Not every pope can be a John XXIII. We are in good shape if we
have one every century.
Gary MacEoins e-mail is gmaceoin@cs.com
National Catholic Reporter, October 8,
1999
|
|