Back to drawing board on Ex Corde
Ecclesiae
By PAMELA
SCHAEFFER NCR Staff
Its back to work for U.S. Catholic bishops who have spent
the past six years in a painstaking effort to adapt the Vatican document Ex
Corde Ecclesiae to the standards of Catholic colleges and universities in
the United States.
The Vatican Congregation on Catholic Education has delivered four
pages of criticisms on a draft prepared by bishops and academics working under
the direction of Bishop John J. Leibrecht of Springfield-Cape Girardeau, Mo. --
an effort widely praised in the U.S. academic world and approved by bishops
last November by a vote of 224-6. The document was then sent to the Vatican for
approval.
Ex Corde Ecclesiae (From the Heart of the
Church), Pope John Paul IIs 1990 Apostolic Constitution on Higher
Education, directs Catholic colleges and universities to affirm their Catholic
identity and take steps to safeguard and perpetuate their Catholic missions.
Bishops committees in each country were to develop local norms.
The latest development is not a setback but a continuation,
Leibrecht said in a telephone interview with NCR. Weve been
working a long time with university presidents and bishops, and the next step
is to work with the Holy See.
The Vatican has also asked for more study of the U.S.
bishops 1989 document that proposes guidelines for due process when
conflicts develop between theologians and local bishops. That document is
titled Doctrinal Responsibilities: Approaches to Promoting Cooperation
and Resolving Misunderstandings Between Bishops and Theologians.
Monika K. Hellwig, executive director of the Association of
Catholic Colleges and Universities, told NCR that the word from the
Vatican is perhaps disappointing but not surprising. Many had hoped the
document would be accepted in its present form, but we would have expected some
negotiation, she said.
The most difficult point in the document for U.S. academics -- and
one carefully sidestepped in the draft rejected by the Vatican Congregation for
Catholic Education -- is implementation of canon 812 in the churchs Code
of Canon Law. The canon states, Those who teach theological subjects in
any institute of higher studies must have a mandate from the competent
ecclesiastical authority -- in effect, the local bishop.
Although Ex Corde Ecclesiae is aimed at Catholic schools
worldwide, its primary effect is in the United States, where some 230 Catholic
colleges and universities enroll more than 600,000 students -- far more than in
any other country. Many U.S. academics are deeply disturbed by the implications
of Canon 812 for academic freedom and possibly for government funding. In
recent decades, state and federal funds have become critical to ongoing
research and even survival at many schools.
In response to the Vaticans request for a new draft, Bishop
Anthony M. Pilla of Cleveland, president of the National Conference of Catholic
Bishops, has appointed a subcommittee headed by Cardinal Anthony J. Bevilacqua
of Philadelphia to work on the revision.
Bevilacqua was among the sharpest critics of the U.S. draft sent
to Rome. He challenged what he regarded as its failure to address the
requirements of canon 812. He voted in favor of accepting the document last
November, but only after a footnote was added saying U.S. bishops would give
further study to Canon 812s requirements.
Leibrecht said the Vatican has also asked for more explicit
directives on the essential elements of mission statements that
educational institutions are required to develop, as well as revised language
that is more canonical.
Leibrecht said he expects the new subcommittee to be sensitive to
the characteristics of higher education distinctive to the United States.
I dont know what their recommendations will be, but I have no doubt
they will look at Canon 812 in light of the historical experience of Catholic
higher education in the United States, he said.
According to a May 27 news release from the National Conference of
Catholic Bishops, Cardinal Pio Laghi, head of the Vatican Congregation for
Catholic Education, presented four pages of observations on the
draft, along with a request for a new one, to Pilla when he and other bishops
met with Vatican officials in May.
The news release contained some quotations from the observations.
But a bishops conference spokeswoman, Mercy Sr. Mary Ann Walsh, said the
full text would not be released. Appointed to Bevilacquas subcommittee
were Cardinal Adam J. Maida of Detroit; Bishop Thomas G. Doran of Rockford,
Ill.; Bishop Raymond L. Burke of La Crosse, Wis.; and Msgr. John Alesandro, an
episcopal vicar of the Rockville Centre, N.Y., diocese.
Alesandro is a canon lawyer, as are all bishops on the
subcommittee, according to Leibrecht.
The subcommittee is to serve under Leibrechts original
committee, which is composed of seven bishops, eight university presidents and
consultors. The committee developed its draft based on broad consultation with
U.S. academics, who met with local bishops around the country.
In a memo to bishops and Catholic academic leaders regarding the
new development, Leibrecht said he and other bishops on his committee will meet
with Laghi and the staff of his congregation in Rome to discuss their
concerns.
Leibrecht said he expected colleges and universities to continue
their ongoing dialogues on identity and mission, guided by the
principles of Ex Corde Ecclesiae. The document, his memo said,
offers insights and challenges for local dialogues and professional
associations, which can be constructively addressed now.
In the news release, the National Conference of Catholic Bishops
said that Laghi had expressed profound gratitude for the work of
U.S. bishops thus far.
(This article contains information from Catholic News
Service.)
National Catholic Reporter, June 6,
1997
|