Column Catholic Charities deals with 'welfare repeal'
By THOMAS C.
FOX
The initial shock has worn off and a new determination seems to be
setting in among Catholic Charities officials nationwide as they attempt to
make the best out of bad -- and what many consider potentially catastrophic --
social policy one year after President Clinton signed legislation ending a half
century of federal assistance to the country's poor.
The date the president signed the bill -- Aug. 22, 1996 -- stands
out painfully in the memories of those who attended the annual Catholic
Charities meeting in West Palm Beach, Fla., earlier this month. That was the
day they and thousands of other social service providers and advocates were
forced to admit defeat. Catholic Charities USA actively opposed the welfare
legislation.
Yes, reform was needed in welfare assistance, Catholic Charities
staff members will tell you. But what the nation got was not reform. In the
words of Sister of Mercy Maureen Joyce, diocesan director of Catholic Charities
in Albany, N.Y., it was simply "welfare repeal."
"That was the motive," she said. "That was the intent."
No one at the gathering believed for a minute that counties,
working with private agencies will adequately provide needed services as the
law envisions. That's what is frightening. The closer you get, the worse it
looks. Prospects of hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of people in dire
poverty, perhaps with no shelter and minimal food, heating and medicine are
real and haunting thoughts.
Much remains uncertain. States are to wean federal aid recipients
off welfare rolls over the next 18 months to five years or face stiff
penalties. The scope of the proposed change, meanwhile, continues to boggle the
mind. No one claims to have a handle on exactly what the nation will go through
in the years ahead.
Catholic Charities officials, still disappointed that Clinton
signed the bill, talk about it as a "grand experiment," unprecedented in scope
and spawned not by reason and intellectual persuasion but by pernicious myth
and political ideology.
Meanwhile, Catholic Charities USA has learned many lessons in the
past two years and is more coordinated and aggressive than ever before in
lobbying local legislators to delay cutoff dates and rectify the worst of
proposed and enacted legislation. Victories are being reported as some
legislators step back from the brink.
Catholic Charities USA has made some modest changes to enable it
to gather and disseminate information to dioceses more quickly: weekly
"advofaxes," a new Web site and two full-time national staff members focusing
on information and lobbying efforts.
Last year, Joyce says, the nation -- Catholics included --
swallowed the myth of the welfare cheat "and in the process stripped the poor
of their dignity."
She and others continue to insist that the target of blame should
be poverty, not the poor. She says most welfare recipients are elderly persons
in nursing homes, and young children.
It is easy to sense bitterness just below the surface among those
who watched as poor people were scapegoated.
These Catholic social advocates will say that as Christians they
remain hopeful, though hardly optimistic.
Bitterness surfaces when they speak about Clinton, who has boasted
that "welfare reform is working" as welfare rolls drop. Yes, drops are
occurring, they say, and the new legislation has probably played a role. But
the strongest economy in years has played a greater role.
More important, those who have come off social service rolls have
been "the cream of the crop."
Ernie Giron, vice president and division director of Catholic
Charities in Fort Collins, Colo., said he expects welfare reform to get good
press in Colorado over the next 12 to 18 months as recipient numbers drop,
perhaps by a third. That's when the easy cases will leave the rolls, including
the educated and those temporarily out of work. Eventually, "we will get to the
hard core -- those without job skills, job habits, those largely incapable of
holding jobs, including the 50 percent without high school education or less."
Giron says the real problem will come when counties demand
employment for people without skills and, in some cases, without hope of
developing them. "We're waiting for the dike to break. It's like not knowing
before you experience the devastation of a flood what it will be like. Only
afterward will we face the enormity of the disaster."
Other service providers point to further complications: Little or
no daycare for mothers working second and third shifts, inadequate
transportation for the poor -- and always the threat of a recession. What
happens, they ask, when the economy goes sour -- as one day it will -- and
funding, already short and getting shorter, comes nowhere near meeting greater
needs.
Finally, with millions entering the job market at minimum wage in
the next several years, they say, expect increasingly depressed wages at the
lower end of the income spectrum. For any hope of livable wages, the minimum
wage will have to be raised dramatically. Politically, the odds are it is not
going to happen, they say.
"The most immediate concern," said Patrick J. Johnson Jr., chair
of the board of trustees of Catholic Charities USA, "is the inadequacy of job
opportunities for the poor. The jobs they qualify for are most often part-time,
contain no medical benefits and have no job path, no hope for decent wages or
advancement."
Johnson spoke of the culture of hopelessness among the poor and a
national myth of rugged individualism run amuck. "None of us have made it on
our own. We Catholics need to bring to the cultural debate our religious sense
of the common good, the notion that we act out of moral obligation and the need
to sacrifice for a greater good. The most evident of those who cannot give back
what they take are children. Can't we see it?"
So far, of course, many do not see it. The question in the minds
of the many thousands who make up Catholic Charities, the largest private human
services organization in the country, is, How dark will it have to get before
people see the light?
Tom Fox is NCR's publisher.
National Catholic Reporter, September 19,
1997
|