Inside NCR
From Iraq to Guatemala, the perils of
intruding
Saddam Hussein is one big conundrum. I have no trouble confessing
I profoundly dislike him. Millions of words are blowing in the wind about how
to cope: whether to pulverize him and half his country, while wasting some
innocents as collateral; or to save the innocent and let Saddam
build bad bombs to kill other innocents later.
The United States has remarkably few allies in the rush to
pulverize. Do they know something we dont?
Few nations go to war for good reasons. When George Bushs
Iraq war was over, many attitudes could be summed up in the title of NCR
publisher Tom Foxs book, Military Victory, Moral Defeat. Bush said
the war was for democracy, in Kuwait of all places. But in a moment of candor
his secretary of state, James Baker, admitted it was all about jobs,
jobs, jobs.
Jobs for us, obviously, not for the Iraqis, especially the dead
ones.
This brings us to the man on the NCR cover. Its not
an easy decision to put such a picture up front. Guatemala is one of many
countries where the United States, in the supposed interests of democracy, has
aided repressive regimes in snuffing out opposition. Our man on the cover was
presumably a member of that opposition. He looks so harmless now, so pathetic,
while the United States forges ahead toward ever greater prosperity and
power.
If this sounds like U.S.-bashing, remember that self-criticism is
a civic as well as a personal duty. The United States, it should quickly be
said, is one of the most generous countries in the world, and one of the most
idealistic, and poor people worldwide are grateful for its largess and
impressed by its vitality and can-do attitudes.
But every time a foreign power intrudes aggressively in the
affairs of another nation, the result is dead bodies and broken nations -- that
is in capsule the history of the world. The United States in its idealism
doesnt seem to see that yet. It often takes many centuries for the
violence to come home to roost. The former Yugoslavia is a story of old
intrusions come home to roost, as is Northern Ireland. The seeds of the
massacres in Rwanda were sown by colonialism long ago, as were similar violent
seeds in dozens of places around the world.
Its not that there would have been perfect peace in any
case. So what is an idealist to do? If we had an easy answer to that, the world
would be beating a path to our door; or perhaps not.
But there is a strong hint here that we should welcome the
initiatives of countries, such as Guatemala, which is prepared to look back and
face its community memory with all its scars. And likewise South Africa, and
perhaps others. They are trying, as few nations have done, to look at the past
honestly and learn from it. Here in the United States, it might be the
patriotic thing to do.
The Catholic Press Association has announced that normal
professional practices will not be restricted at future CPA meetings. The
statement itself cries out for explanation.
It all began last year when the keynote speaker at the annual CPA
meeting in Denver was Clarissa Pinkola Estés, who forbade the
journalists present from recording her or taking photos. To repeat, this was a
national press convention. The subject of her talk, which must have been
tongue-in-cheek, was The Voice of the Catholic Press.
We need to declare ourselves here. Managing Editor Tom Roberts,
representing NCR, taped every word. No, he didnt wire himself like
Linda Tripp; he boldly placed that old recorder on the table -- the dinner was
good, he says -- and the glint in his eye says he secretly hoped someone would
challenge him but no one did.
The CPA boards recent statement declared: We find it
totally inconsistent with our mission and actually insulting to our
professionalism that we would be denied the opportunity to photograph or tape
record a convention speech without serious cause. Why nobody jumped in
headlong to defend this principle at the time will remain a mystery. But two
cheers for this belated clarification.
In this time when news leaks proliferate, heres one for us:
a reliable ear-to-the-ground source in St. Louis reports that the St. Louis
University Hospital saga is far from over. Recall that last year, the
university board had all but sold the teaching hospital to Tenet, a for-profit
chain, for $300 million, when Archbishop Justin Rigali and other prominent U.S.
church leaders cried foul .
Wed heard that Rigali and Jesuit Fr. Lawrence Biondi, the
universitys president, had been meeting regularly of late. Now Jerry
Berger, St. Louis Post-Dispatch columnist, said in his Feb. 4 report
that a lawyer close to the negotiations promises a Vatican-sanctioned
settlement on the horizon -- one that will involve a certain amount
of face-saving and a large amount of cash. Berger says to expect an
announcement within weeks.
Our sources tell us that Tenet will get the hospital, despite
opposition from Rigali and a pack of red hats. Apparently principal, not
principle, will win the day.
If you think this is not important, reflect on all the similar
hospitals, universities and other such institutions around the country that
could be further bones of contention as religious orders and other Catholics
downsize, signs of the times.
|