EDITORIAL Guatemala offers a bit of history we dare not
forget
As the United States, in its
military campaigns against countries such as Iraq and Yugoslavia, tries to
position itself as moral arbiter for the post-Cold War world, a pesky bit of
history keeps nipping at its heels.
News from Guatemala keeps threatening to drag us down from the
moral heights with memories of that cold war when, in the name of fighting
communism, the United States engaged in some reprehensible behavior.
First came the April 1998 report compiled by the Catholic
churchs three-year Interdiocesan Project to Recover the Historic
Memory. Titled Guatemala: Never Again, the report blamed the
Guatemalan military for the bulk of the violence during the countrys
36-year civil war that ended with the signing of peace accords in December 1996
(NCR, Feb. 13 and May 8, 1998).
The church report was followed by a United Nations-sponsored truth
report released in February of this year that described the actions of the
Guatemalan government during the 36-year civil war as genocide. The report also
held the United States responsible for supporting a succession of brutal
military dictators, for using the Central Intelligence Agency to aid the
Guatemalan military and for training Guatemalan army officials in
counterinsurgency tactics that resulted in widespread torture and death
(NCR, March 12).
The information in those reports was gathered through extensive
interviews and painstaking work that involved exhuming bodies from mass, secret
graves.
Now comes a report from inside the government and military
structure detailing the armys intent, a gruesome logbook containing
photographs and coded references to executions of 183 victims.
It is the only known record of its kind.
The revelation of the logbook has brought some measure of comfort
to Guatemalan families who at least now know the ultimate fate of loved ones
who have been disappeared for years.
But it ought to make U.S. officials increasingly uneasy. The
United States has never adequately dealt with this sinister piece of history
and its involvement in it.
It also complicates U.S. concern over refugees and oppressed
people elsewhere when it keeps coming out that this country was complicit in
atrocities that are strikingly similar to the gruesome deeds of Yugoslav
President Slobodan Milosovec and his thugs.
The numbers may have been smaller, but in those 36 civil war
years, 200,000 people were killed, mostly Mayans, and hundreds of thousands
more became refugees, some wandering inside Guatemala and many trying to
escape.
Unlike the attention given Kosovar refugees, no cameras
concentrated for countless days on the Guatemalans perilous trek into
Mexico or their dangerous attempts to make it to the United States. And those
who made it here were not greeted by legions of humanitarian workers and
worldwide concern. They had to seek sanctuary because the United States deemed
them economic, not political refugees. How could they be political refugees
from a regime the United States was supporting?
This logbook revelation will not be the last.
It is time for the United States to come clean on its long
involvement in Guatemala, no matter how embarrassing.
If there is any consistency to President Clintons concern
for oppressed cultures and exploited refugees, he should open the considerable
U.S. archives on the period and allow the story to be told in full.
National Catholic Reporter, May 28,
1999
|