EDITORIAL Clintons poverty tour misses the larger
point
Cresident Bill Clintons
decision to visit desperately poor rural and urban settings was a laudable
gesture, calling attention to not only the invisible millions whom the economic
boom has passed by but also, in the case of Native Americans, to those still
suffering from centuries of injustice.
With 18 months to go in office, Slobodan Milosevic on the ropes
and the economy so hot that a common problem is worker shortages, Clinton
understandably might decide to coast the rest of the way.
To his credit, he decided instead to focus national attention on
the 35 million Americans who have been left behind.
In the wake of the noble gesture, of course, is the overriding
question, What can he do?
For what becomes evident in the context of this opportunity taken
are the more significant opportunities either missed or intentionally
avoided.
What Clinton can do immediately is bring along the considerable
credibility he seems to have with the business community as well as a solid
track record of creating jobs. According to news reports, a combination of new
and existing programs is expected to pump up to $15 billion in private sector
funds into poor rural and urban communities.
It is a fairly safe bet that the follow-up to Clintons trip
will be some new housing for migrants, new loan possibilities for poor
communities and new retail establishments in locations that too long have
remained off the site-selection maps of major chains and lending
institutions.
Without impugning motives, what clearly is at work here is
Clintons almost unerring political instincts. Timing is everything: This
is the time, the prosperous time, when the rest of the country will find
initiatives toward the poor easy to tolerate.
The downside, of course, is that using such a calculus, as Clinton
has done his entire tenure, squeezes out the possibility of the truly large
gesture, the fashioning of a national purpose that relies more on a classic
sense of government as an agent of the common good than on the latest
polls.
Good political instincts say, as Clinton has, If we
cant do it now, well never get it done. The healthier
national purpose would say, Were all the more impoverished if we
arent getting it done.
Clintons solutions are his global approach applied to the
local community. It is an approach in which government abdicates its leadership
functions to the marketplace, becoming a facilitator of bids and investment
options.
In this context, leading with the market is charity disguised as
justice. Justice changes systems, markets exploit them. Justice advocates for
the long haul, markets are a short-term fix. The market can only turn a buck,
and thats not enough where much in peoples lives needs to be turned
around.
People may make money, but the deeper human needs -- health care,
education, better schools, child care, personal dignity and self-esteem -- will
remain largely untouched unless someone is willing and able to galvanize the
national will to something larger.
National Catholic Reporter, July 16,
1999
|