Column Wiggle room, common sense will save church from Ex
Corde
By TIM UNSWORTH
Theres been so much blather
about the apostolic constitution Ex Corde Ecclesiae that I finally
decided to do the unthinkable: I read the damn thing. No one reads apostolic
constitutions unless suffering from insomnia. Its like moving wet cement
with ones eyelashes.
The local chancery kindly faxed me a copy, and I plowed through
its lengthy filigreed sentences while struggling with the curly fax parchment.
It was a test of faith.
An apostolic constitution is always solemn in form and legal in
content. It deals with faith, doctrine and discipline and is usually issued in
the form of a bull because it is closed with a bulla (Latin for
seal.) Constitutions are generally signed by the pope and often contain
postscripts written by lesser prelates who translate the popes urgings
into marching orders. Apostolic constitutions are considered the highest form
of legislative documents. Ignore one and you run the risk of not passing
Go or collecting $200.
Ex Corde Ecclesiae appeared in 1990. Basically, it was
intended to define the relationship between the church and Catholic
institutions of higher learning throughout the world. The Vatican seemed
particularly concerned about what had already happened in Europe -- namely that
the universities would drift away from their Catholic moorings. The Vatican
feared that this would happen elsewhere in the world, particularly in the
United States.
The U.S. church boasts 240 colleges and universities (five of them
in Puerto Rico). In 1998, they educated 692,951 students, just a little more
than 1 percent of the U.S. Catholic population.
However, degreed Catholics count a little more than the nearly 99
percent without blessed sheepskins.
Only six states have no Catholic institution of higher learning --
none of them particularly Catholic states. Six others have 107 colleges or
universities or 45 percent of the total. There are 30 in New York alone and 26
in neighboring Pennsylvania, many of them outgrowths of religious novitiates.
The schools average just under 3,000 students per campus, but 20 percent of the
total are studying at just 10 large universities. In spite of increasingly
higher tuition, business is good. Total enrollment has increased by 129,000 in
the past decade.
Higher education institutions love to parse and expand upon even a
low-level interoffice memo. It was almost six years before the National
Conference of Catholic Bishops submitted its implementation document on Ex
Corde to the Vatican, which is still parsing Inquisition documents.
In 1996, the Vatican rejected as insufficient the revised document
that had been overwhelmingly accepted by the American bishops. By 1998, the 284
voting bishops were asked to vote on a revised response. The vote was delayed
pending more dialogue with the top administrators of the colleges. Now, the
document comes up for its second vote at the November gathering of the bishops.
The poor bishops are caught in a species of Hobsons choice -- an
apparently free choice that offers no alternative. (Thomas Hobson, keeper of a
livery stable, required that customers either take the horse nearest the door
or none at all.) In addition, the bishops must face the fact that their
conference has virtually no power.
Dont fight this [document], one high-ranking
bishop is said to have urged the presidents. Its coming in.
Lets try to make the best of it.
But the institutional presidents are still objecting to the
specifics of the document that they feel may be attempting to turn colleges and
universities into grammar schools. In the implementation that was drawn from
the document, there is talk of all-Catholic boards of trustees, mostly Catholic
professors, course loads that require old-fashioned doses of theology and
philosophy, theology courses that are carefully vetted for content, and the
bishop as chief monitor of theological curricula.
In an article that appeared in the Jan. 30 issue of
America, Holy Cross Fr. Edward A. Malloy, president of the University of
Notre Dame, and Jesuit Fr. J. Donald Monan, chancellor of Boston College,
(combined enrollment over 25,000) termed the document profoundly
detrimental to Catholic higher education.
The bishops are reluctant to cross crosiers with mortarboards. For
the most part, they have enjoyed friendly relationships with their local
colleges, most of which have bestowed honorary degrees on them.
If the Catholic character of these institutions has been diluted,
it might only be a matter of perception. Years ago, many of them were Catholic
ghettos with limited curricula and faculties at least half of whom were dressed
in habits that carried more weight than their academic credentials. If a
non-Catholic student enrolled, the student newspaper would likely carry an
article that headlined: Jewish student says he likes Thomistic
philosophy.
I recall one Catholic college that banned National
Geographic from its library (something to do with those native women), and
I knew a girl who was fed saltpeter in her oatmeal to calm her urges. There was
a time when one could get a Catholic degree without ever visiting the college
library, which had lots of books in locked cases.
Today, on balance, Catholic colleges and universities are stronger
-- and thus more Catholic -- than ever.
Surely, the loss of religious has had an effect on the Catholic
image associated with these institutions. A school with only five religious on
its over 1,600-member faculty can hardly proclaim a congregations
philosophy, although lay teachers can transmit a good portion of it.
I have been impressed by the efforts at most universities to
transmit both faith and practice on Catholic campuses.
Georgetown University has recently added a Muslim chaplain. It
caused so much noise that observers might have neglected to note that the
school has 20 chaplains. A few years ago, when the late former bishop of Fort
Wayne-South Bend, Ind., home to Notre Dame, visited the pope, John Paul II
asked him: Do the boys go to Mass? (He seemed unaware that the
school had gone coed.)
When informed that the university had at least 18 Masses each
weekend and that at least 80 percent of the students attended, the pope faced a
crisis of belief. The Vatican is lucky to get 80 percent of its cardinals to
Mass.
Sociology professor, Robert N. Bellah, co-author of Habits of
the Heart, spoke at Jesuit-run Regis University in Denver not long ago. His
powerful talk was digested in America (July 31 issue). Bellah reminded
his audience of G.K. Chestertons dictum that, in America, all Catholics
are Protestants.
Theres much more to Bellahs statement than that, but
essentially he teaches that we must not overlook the culture in which American
Catholics live. Our faith is tinged with a Puritan streak that got off the boat
well before European Catholics arrived.
It has tinged the beliefs of Baptist John Winthrop and Quaker
Roger Williams. It embraces the philosophy of Thomas Jefferson and the deism of
George Washington.
American Catholicism is as much Protestant as it is Italian,
Latino, Irish, German, Polish or Middle European. We cant legislate it
back to the lower decks of the boats that brought us here.
But back to Ex Corde Ecclesiae. The 20-page letter has much
that is pastoral. John Paul calls the university an incomparable center
of creativity and dissemination of knowledge.
A former professor himself with two earned doctorates, its
clear that the pope values the life of the mind. He is quick to praise those
involved in both research and education. But there is an undercurrent of fear
that the theological packaging isnt wrapped carefully enough.
Yet, there is room. Part II of the document takes back much of
Part I by the use of qualifying phrases that supply lots of wiggle room. Dennis
OBrien, president emeritus of the University of Rochester in New York,
calls them loopholes. Writing in the July 31 issue of
America, OBrien cites phrases such as as much as
possible and to the extent possible. There is a sprinkling of
shoulds such as the president should be a faithful
Catholic. The answer is clear: The president need not be a Catholic. Even
in Part I, the pope writes that Bishops should encourage the creative
work of theologians and that bishops should not be seen as external
agents.
There remains lots of room for bishops. The late Cardinal Joseph
Bernardin of Chicago assigned theological responsibility to the presidents of
the six colleges and universities in his archdiocese.
When glitches occurred, Bernardin would simply contact the local
president and talk it over. No oath taking; no theological vetting.
It all had something to do with trust.
God knows how this next vote will go. But if the bishops decide to
face Rome rather than their people, it may not be all that bad. Trustees,
administrators, faculty and students can find some wiggle room until the
document moves slowly to a back shelf and a new pope writes something that
rescinds it.
A few wacky bishops will try to implement the specifics.
Most will hope that it just sits on the shelf in the
presidents office, gathering dust.
Somewhere in California, there is a dear old lady named Rose
Lucey, who used to be on the board of this distinguished newspaper. She is the
mother of 10 children and the author of a small book on child rearing titled
Roots and Wings. Give them roots, her book said. Then,
give them wings.
Perhaps we simply need Roses formula rather than slipping
into deceptive legalism.
Tim Unsworth writes from Chicago. You can reach him at
unsworth@megsinet.net
National Catholic Reporter, November 5,
1999
|