For Israelis, papal visit struck a deep
chord
By BEN LYNFIELD
Special to the National Catholic
Reporter Jerusalem
Avraham Gleicher, a 42-year-old optician and Orthodox Jew,
surprised himself during Pope John Paul IIs visit to the Holy Land. He
developed strong feelings of affection for the leader of the Catholic
church.
For Gleicher, Christianity and Catholicism were - and remain -
associated mostly with persecution of the Jews down the centuries, from the
crusades to the Spanish Inquisition to the silence and perceived inaction of
the Vatican during the Nazi Holocaust.
We have a historical problem with the church, but we
appreciate this man very much, he said. Even those who did not like
the church felt an affinity for him.
Gleicher grinned as he recalled John Paul praying at the Western
Wall, Judaisms holiest site on Sunday, the last day of his visit.
This was a nice visit, he said of the six-day
pilgrimage. There were many beautiful moments.
Added Aviahai Shahar, 21, a soldier: It was clear that he
came here to connect with Judaism, not just Christianity.
Other Israelis cited John Pauls visit to the Yad Vashem
Holocaust Memorial and his poignant encounters there with survivors and old
friends from his native Poland as the highlight of the visit.
Two days after the pope departed, there was a sense that he had
touched the country in a way unseen since Jordans King Hussein three
years ago visited Israelis who had lost children in a shooting attack by a
deranged Jordanian soldier. The king knelt in an unprecedented gesture of
contrition that cut across Arab-Israeli bitterness and hatred and was widely
recalled when he died last year.
The pope clearly struck a powerful chord by evincing kindness,
frailty and love for Jews and the Old Testament tradition. For Israeli leaders,
John Pauls pilgrimage offered proof of a transformation in the Catholic
churchs attitude toward Jews from contempt and hostility to sympathy and
friendship during the period from 1965 to the present.
It was 35 years ago that the Second Vatican Council (1962-65)
promulgated Nostra Aetate, which rejected the idea of Jewish collective
or continuous responsibility for the death of Jesus, affirmed Gods
covenant with the Jewish people as eternal and unbroken, condemned
anti-Semitism and emphasized the Jewish roots of Christianity, a theme stressed
by John Paul during his pilgrimage.
Under John Pauls leadership, the Vatican recognized Israel
in 1993, after the signing of the Israel-PLO Declaration of Principles.
Analysts differed over how long lasting the impact of the visit
would be or whether the Israeli affection would - or could - reach beyond John
Paul himself to encompass the larger community he represents.
For most people this was a gigantic media event. Any changes
[in attitude toward Christianity] will be superficial, said Tom Segev,
author of The Seventh Million, a book about the relationship between the
Holocaust and Zionism. Israelis learned to like the pope. But their
feelings were concentrated on his personality. It wasnt a deeper
encounter with Christianity.
Most Israelis dont know anything about
Christianity, he added. The deeper changes should start with
textbooks. You have to know something about Christianity before attitudes can
be changed.
The assessment contrasted sharply with the ebullient view of Haim
Ramon, the Israeli minister in charge of the popes visit. I believe
that this visit brings an end to the era of conflict, the era of dispute and
the era of war between Christianity and Judaism, Ramon said. After
2,000 years that these two great monotheistic religions fought each other and
in the Christian case even discriminated, deported, murdered, tortured - that
era is coming to an end.
Joseph Alpher, former head of Tel Aviv Universitys Jaffee
Center for Strategic Studies, noted that Israels main religious parties
boycotted the visit in an indication that for them the enmity and suspicion was
not diminishing.
At the Western Wall, the last remnant of the Temple destroyed by
the Romans in 70 A.D., John Paul followed Jewish tradition by placing a note
between the crevices, intended as a request for God. The text was taken from a
speech in Rome he made earlier this month, expressing sorrow for past misdeeds
of the church. God of our fathers, you chose Abraham and his descendants
to bring your name to the nations: We are deeply saddened by the behavior of
those who in the course of history have caused these children of yours to
suffer, and asking your forgiveness, we wish to commit ourselves to genuine
brotherhood with the people of the Covenant.
The text and other statements by the pope underscored a bid to
stress the common ground between Jews and Christians, said Alpher. The
message I got from the pope is that Catholics are interested in looking at
their roots in Old Testament Judaism.
But beyond speeches and texts, the image of the elderly pontiff
bending over in prayer at the Wall will endure for a long time, said Shlomo
Avineri, former director general of the Israeli foreign ministry. This is
a picture that will appear in the history books - both Catholic and
Jewish, he predicted.
At Yad Vashem, the pope said: Let us build a new future in
which there will be no more anti-Jewish feeling among Christians or
anti-Christian feeling among Jews, but rather the mutual respect required of
those who adore the one Creator and Lord and look to Abraham as our common
father in faith.
Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak, after recounting the
extermination of his Polish Jewish grandparents at Treblinka, responded:
And I can say, Your Holiness, that your coming here today, to the Tent of
Remembrance at Yad Vashem, is a climax of this historic journey of healing.
Here, right now, time itself has come to a standstill. This very moment holds
within it 2000 years of history, and their weight is almost too much to
bear.
One survivor, Edith Tzirer, wept as she told the pope he had saved
her life in 1945, when he was a young priest, by giving her food and carrying
her on his back for three kilometers when she was drained of strength. I
thought he was God himself, she told a television interviewer, in
recalling the incident. (The popes official Polish biographer later said
he thought Tzirer may have been confused about the identity of the person who
assisted her. Karol Wojtyla, who became John Paul II, was a seminarian at the
time.)
The pope came across as a survivor during the Yad Vashem
visit, definitely not as an accomplice to the silence of Pius XII, Segev,
the author, said. This was very moving for us. He came across almost as
one of us.
But Segev, writing in the Haaretz daily newspaper,
took issue with the pope for equating anti-Jewish feelings among Christians to
anti-Christian feelings among Jews. Many Jews are indeed hostile to
Christianity, he wrote. But they did not try to force Christians to
convert and they did not persecute them. That is something that Christians did
to Jews.
While there were voices that complained that the pope had stopped
short of apologizing for the silence of Pope Pius, those voices did not
resonate very far. Commentators said such an apology was never a realistic
expectation. Can a church that believes itself to be the repository of
divine truth admit it was basically wrong? Can a pope criticize one of his
predecessors? asked Avineri.
Some people wanted an apology, but what was so impressive
for most was that [during his visit to Israel] the pope radiated so much
dignity and piety and had positive messages and warm things to say, said
Alpher.
Rabbi Ron Kronish, director of the Inter-Religious Coordinating
Council in Israel, said that the process of reconciliation with Judaism
is now entrenched in the church. The new thinking on the Jews is church
[policy]. It would take an extremely conservative pope to undo all of this. I
dont think its possible. A conservative pope could come in and slow
it down perhaps.
There have been major changes during the last 35 years. This
visit by the pope was a series of milestones in those changes, and I think it
will have a lasting effect, Kronish said. Its not just this
person, but the church itself. Of course, this person being the Polish pope,
coming from where he came from, knowing Jews, added a very special personal
[element] to it. I think it will go on.
National Catholic Reporter, April 7,
2000
|