EDITORIAL Colombia aid a dangerous mistake
In a vote that drew relatively
little notice, the House recently approved a bill that included $1.7 billion in
military aid to fund drug interdiction operations in Colombia.
That figure is up from $65 million in 1996 and $300 million last
year (see story on page 12). While the Senate has yet to consider the request,
observers believe the Colombia package will not face much opposition.
It strains the imagination to see how this explosion of aid to the
military of one of the most unsettled countries in South America fits into any
rational foreign policy or into a war on drug use in the United States, the
prime recipient of Colombian coca production.
Plenty of credible voices question the wisdom of taking the fight
against U.S. drug use to rural Colombia, where insurgents and drug runners have
carved out the equivalent of their own little countries.
Experts point out that even if military action were successful in
shutting down the Colombian operation, the drug producers and everyone else
profiting from the addictions on the streets of the United States will simply
shift their location, take up in another region of Colombia or another country
altogether. As long as the demand remains high enough, the drugs will flow.
Critics say a more effective strategy would be to concentrate on
eliminating the demand here, a strategy that would require as dramatic a
gesture toward education and rehabilitation -- in terms of spending and
commitment -- as the military initiative. But that would also mean turning away
from the easy fix, from the military addiction that is as deep and damaging to
our culture as its drug addictions.
At least as dangerous as the misplaced strategy is the real threat
of a military escalation of the kind that occurred in Vietnam and the danger of
complicity in human rights abuses that occurred in El Salvador, Guatemala,
Nicaragua and elsewhere in Latin America.
No one needs to do much theorizing to draw out the details of the
danger. A quick dip into recent history will do.
It was only a year ago that President Clinton apologized to
Guatemalans for the significant role the United States played in propping up
vicious military regimes during that countrys 30-year civil war that
ended with 200,000 disappeared or murdered, mostly innocent civilians, and a
huge internal refugee population.
Clinton said the policy was wrong and vowed, The United
States must not repeat that mistake.
For this administration, advocating the billion-dollar military
adventure is a drastic and dangerous change in policy from earlier years.
Arming the Colombian military to the teeth for an anti-insurgency war is
repeating previous mistakes and magnifying them many times over.
National Catholic Reporter, April 14,
2000
|